Atlas Said, "Come Again?"
Posted on 03.19.07 by Widge @ 8:47 am

This is rough. Check out this latest missive from the Pirate Bay guys.

Now look at this line:

Democracy is about freedom and its foundation lies within the fact that everyone has the right to all information, culture and creativity.

Now, from what Wikipedia tells me about Sweden, it's a "representative parliamentary democracy under a constitutional monarchy," which I think is safe to assume is correct since to my knowledge Stephen Colbert does not have Sweden in his crosshairs at this time. So I'll give him that. Still, he's not living in a pure democracy, because as I believe we've said before, democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting as to what's for lunch.

But still, does anybody here really think that the foundation of democracy, the rule of the people, is that the people get all information, culture and creative stuff for free? I thought the foundation of democracy was the direct participation of citizens in government. Granted, I went to school in Alabama, but I think it was something like that.

And where–anywhere–does it say that you have the right–not the option, mind you, but the right–to download the latest Bruce Springsteen album free of charge?

Now, to quote Uncle Bill, "I'm with the invaders. No use trying to hide that." Of course, the next bit is something to the effect of "But I disagree with some of what they are doing."

And here we go.

Let's not have anybody stupidly running around saying that they have a right to get shit for free. For example, the only reason you can get my books for free–or at least, digital versions of them–is because I have decided to make them available for free. So you have no right to jack shit of mine, Mikael. As I've stated before, if it's my choice to make it available for free, I will more than likely do so, but if you come around here pissing and moaning about your right to my books, then I'd rather burn the fuckers than let you have them under those terms.

The battle you're fighting is to get businesses to change their business model so that what you're doing can be seen as a bonus for them if nothing else. They have to be convinced that piracy, or what they define as piracy, actually can generate sales as opposed to killing them off completely.

But if you go around saying that piracy's good because it gets you the shit you want for free, well, the companies are going to go down fighting you. Because in that scenario, they can't win. You see, creating this stuff takes time, talent and money. And while the people reading me right now are thinking, "Yeah, Widge, but those companies you're defending gave us Batman and Robin, Joey and The DaVinci Code." To which I say, "Yeah, but they also brought you Batman Begins, Deadwood and Harry Potter." They have been known to provide a bit of entertainment in their time.

If you kill the companies by demanding that you get their shit for free, then what are we left with? Watching teenagers act stupid on YouTube? Are you really telling me that you would support the guys who made House (the series, not the movie franchise mind you) to go make it without a network's support? Wait, no, Mikael, of course not–because you have the right to that series without paying a dime–anywhere, anytime. That means you should be able to get it commercial free and on demand, and the networks should just suck it up and deal.

So, Mikael, you're not helping. Get your shit together. There is a way that this can end with everybody happy, but if you're demanding everything for nothing then no one's going to take you seriously. And the artists who do actually sort of agree with most of what you're up to–like me–are going to leave you for the wolves because you've gotten out of line with too many imaginary "rights."


Taggification: ,

Filed under: Ranting
Comments:

« You Can Have Too Much of a Good Thing | Biometrics for a Beemer? » 1 Comment »

  1. It's becoming a battle of who is the biggest asshole.

    The RIAA and others sue anyone and everyone to "protect artists' copyright" [translation: rake up some lawyer's fees], so the Pirate Bay guys overreact and say we want everything free, thinking this will hurt the corporations. Of course, the actual content creator gets lost in the barrages of subpeona and press release.

    Comment by ScottC — March 19, 2007 @ 2:12 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)



John Robinson is a writer of prose, poetry and comics who also writes under the pseudonym of Widgett Walls.

Widgett Walls is the director of Needcoffee.com who also writes under the pseudonym of John Robinson.

Don't ask.


This is my latest book. Short stories written especially for you, or at least someone who reminded me a lot of you at the time.

Read it for free here. Or if you like paper, buy it here.

Then tell all your friends about it. Or all your enemies. I'm not particular either way.


Want a translation? Try these:

They're not perfect, but they'll do in a pinch.







Syndication
Feedburner

Amigos
Sarah Brown
Catalyst
Dindrane
Doc Ezra
Tee Quillin
ScottC
Tibby's Bowl
JM Tuffley

Sites Which Distract Me From Writing
Boing Boing
Cringely
Defamer
Warren Ellis
Engadget
Fortean Times
Long Tail
Porphyre
Reason
Wired

Topics
General BS
Insomnia
Travel
Writing Fodder

Active Projects...
Dark Blue Monstropolis
Magnificent Desolation
Something Else
The Sunday Before You


Recent Entries
  • And Now That I've Upgraded to 2.6...
  • Don't Mind Me.
  • Amazon MAB Replacement?
  • My New Mascot
  • A Nice Coda to the Trip
  • The New Yorker Hotel Business Center
  • Blast From the Past
  • Crossposted From My StumbleUpon Blog
  • Update at Last
  • George Clooney Makes Small Films Profitable. Yes.
  • On the Other Side of the Flu
  • Piano and Trumpet For the Win
  • Gun, With Occasional Weightlessness
  • Tor Nørretranders on Permanent Reincarnation
  • Can I Get a Hell Yeah?

  • Wordpress Archives
    July 2008
    May 2008
    April 2008
    March 2008
    February 2008
    January 2008
    December 2007
    November 2007
    October 2007
    September 2007
    August 2007
    July 2007
    June 2007
    May 2007
    April 2007
    March 2007
    February 2007
    January 2007
    December 2006
    November 2006
    October 2006
    September 2006
    August 2006
    July 2006
    June 2006
    May 2006
    April 2006
    March 2006
    February 2006
    January 2006
    December 2005
    November 2005
    October 2005
    September 2005
    August 2005
    July 2005
    June 2005
    May 2005
    April 2005
    March 2005

    Credits and Copyright
    Proudly powered by WordPress. All content © 1997-present by John Robinson.
    Theme by Theron Parlin, but we've mangled it beyond all reason. So don't blame him.